We’ve reached the top. Jonathon Brooks came in at number five, Chuba Hubbard at number four, Jalen Coker at number three, and Tetairoa McMillan pushed his way to number two. There was only ever one name that could sit at the summit of this list, and if you follow the pod, you already knew it before you clicked. Panthers fantasy player number one is the quarterback. It’s Bryce Young.
Let me be clear about why the ordering shakes out this way. Positional value settles the argument before we even open the stat sheet. A quarterback touches the ball on every single offensive snap. A running back can lose a workload, a receiver can go three games without a target, but the quarterback’s floor is baked in by the position itself. When you fold in the draft investment, the impact on every other name on this list, and the ceiling attached to the job, there is no honest way to rank a Panthers skill player above the guy throwing them the ball. If Bryce becomes what the pod has been hoping he becomes, his fantasy value blows past everyone else in Carolina, and it isn’t close.
Here’s the case that keeps Bryce at the top. If he turns into a Joe Burrow type of passer, a high-volume, high-efficiency triggerman, then his fantasy value exceeds anything a McMillan or a Hubbard can offer. That’s the bet. And he’s the perfect vehicle for it: young, cheap, on a rookie contract, with a front office and coaching staff still fully invested. Even in the worst-case scenario where Carolina moves on, Bryce is exactly the kind of former number one overall pick who lands a second chance somewhere else. Quarterbacks with his pedigree don’t fall out of the league at 25. That optionality, the chance he breaks out here OR breaks out on a better roster elsewhere, is why he holds the top spot in a way no skill player ever could.
This isn’t blind faith. The arrow is pointing up, and the numbers back it. In 2025, Bryce started 16 games and set career highs across the board: 304-of-478 passing for 3,011 yards, 23 touchdowns against 11 interceptions, a 63.6% completion rate, and an 87.8 passer rating. Those touchdown, yardage, completion, and rating marks were all personal bests. The season ended with Carolina going 8-9 but stealing the NFC South on a three-way tiebreaker, the franchise’s first division title since 2015.
The signature game is the one fantasy managers should tattoo on their brains. In Week 11 against Atlanta, Bryce dropped 448 yards and three scores in an overtime win, erasing Cam Newton’s single-game franchise passing record of 432. That’s the ceiling flashing in real time. The catch, and I won’t hide it from you, is that he topped 200 passing yards once through the first ten weeks before that explosion. This was a boom-or-bust fantasy asset for long stretches of the year.
But zoom out to the bigger sample and it gets more encouraging. Since his 2024 benching, Bryce has made 24 starts and racked up more than 5,000 yards, 42 touchdowns, and just 15 interceptions with a passer rating north of 90, including ten game-winning drives. The advanced numbers moved too. Pro Football Focus charted him with one Big-Time Throw before Week 8 of that stretch and 27 by the end, which tied for seventh in the entire NFL. That’s not noise. That’s a young quarterback learning to pull the trigger downfield.
If you need a reminder of the raw talent, go back to Tuscaloosa. Bryce won the 2021 Heisman throwing for 4,872 yards and 47 touchdowns, both Alabama single-season records. He left as the school’s number two all-time passer with 8,356 yards and 80 touchdowns. The arm talent and processing that made him the number one overall pick never went anywhere. The NFL learning curve was just steeper than anyone wanted.
Why 2026 could be the breakout
Now the setup. Dave Canales is handing play-calling to offensive coordinator Brad Idzik, and the reporting says Bryce will get more freedom to work at the line of scrimmage. That’s the kind of autonomy that unlocks a cerebral quarterback. The weapons are real too. Tetairoa McMillan just won Offensive Rookie of the Year on roughly 1,100 yards and 126 targets, a genuine alpha to grow with. Jalen Coker got paid, three years and $35 million, and rookie Chris Brazzell II adds size on the outside.
For fantasy purposes, temper the redraft expectations. Bryce still profiles as a QB2 in single-quarterback leagues and a rising high-end option in Superflex, where he’s a screaming value. He ranked just 25th in EPA per play last year, so the efficiency has to climb for him to crack the weekly QB1 conversation. But that’s the point of ranking him number one on this list. Everyone else here has a defined ceiling. Bryce Young is the one Panther whose ceiling is a fantasy difference-maker, and in 2026 he’s cheaper than he’ll ever be again. That’s your number one.
Follow me on my free Substack here
