White Sox Land Reliable Arm in Dustin May

The Chicago White Sox’s biggest need going into the offseason was reliable starting pitching. Although they made the postseason last year, they had only one starting pitcher they could trust. In order to repeat that success in 2027, they needed a more stable rotation. They took the first step toward building that rotation by signing Dustin May to a three-year deal worth $52.5 million. This comes out to $17.5 million per season. It is a good first step into fixing this problem. But how does May fit the White Sox, and what work do they still need to do?

How Dustin May Fits the White Sox Rotation

Dustin May is coming off a solid season with both the St. Louis Cardinals and the Milwaukee Brewers. In 31 starts between the two teams, he posted a 4.71 ERA over 145 2/3 innings, with 144 strikeouts to 50 walks, a 1.318 WHIP, and an ERA+ of 85. Sure, these are nowhere near the numbers he had when he was a member of the Los Angeles Dodgers. But he is someone that you can rely on as a mid-rotation arm. Even with him struggling in Milwaukee towards the end of last season, you feel comfortable with him as the fourth in your rotation.

May is the type of pitcher that relies on his stuff to get batters out. He has a six-pitch arsenal but consistently throws only four against righties. His most effective pitch this past season was his four-seam fastball. It was his most used pitch and sat just under 97 mph. His Cutter and Sweeper did not produce great numbers, but the expected batting average was lower than the actual batting average, suggesting he was unlucky. At the same time, his Sinker performed better than expected, so it evens out. He also has a curveball and changeup, which he only throws to righties.

Right now, May is projected as the second or third starter in the rotation. Sean Burke should slot in as the ace of the White Sox staff with Anthony Kay, Davis Martin, and Luis Castillo behind him. The White Sox will also have young guys like Noah Schultz and Grant Taylor who get some turns in the rotation this season. While the young pitchers have upside, the rotation still has a lot of questions. It is still a rotation with question marks and no proven track record of making it through the whole season.

Betr - Official Partner of Blitz Sports Media

While signing May improves the rotation, it is not the only move the White Sox can make. If they could land someone like Sonny Gray or Freddy Peralta, it would give them the much-needed front-line starter they need. But knowing White Sox ownership, these players are well out of their price range. At the very least, they could land someone like Foster Griffin or Jack Flaherty. This would help build a more reliable rotation and help them compete next season.

Sure, it may not be the flashiest move, but May gives the White Sox an arm they know can eat innings. They will not need to piece together a rotation or rely on bullpen games now that May is here.

Screenshot 2026 08 10 120640 5 4

https://discord.gg/tKVupvzmpm

Share Via:
Brian Germinaro
Brian Germinaro