Who Accepted the Qualifying Offers?

The deadline to accept the qualifying offer has passed. Of the eight offers that were extended, only two players accepted. Those were David Bednar of the New York Yankees and Ryan Jeffers of the Minnesota Twins. They will remain with their organization for the 2027 season and be paid $23.15 million. Now Randy Arozarena, Brandon Lowe, Adrian Morejon, Trevor Rogers, and Seiya Suzuki will all have draft pick compensation attached to them. The team that signs them will lose a draft pick and potentially an international sign bonus, while their former team will receive a draft pick.

While you never question why someone accepted a contract that pays them over $20 million, you do have to wonder why Bednar and Jeffers did not test the open market. Both players were expected to be among the best at their positions and could have gotten a better deal. This could have caused them to land big contracts, much better than the qualifying offer. So what led both players to accept these deals?

Why Did David Bednar and Ryan Jeffers Accept the Qualifying Offer?

Let’s start with Bednar, who is coming off yet another strong season. In 69 1/3 innings with the Yankees, he pitched to a 2.47 ERA with 76 strikeouts to 20 walks, a 1.038 WHIP, and a 171 ERA+. He was one of the few bright spots in what was a below-average bullpen for the Bronx Bombers. Bednar has completely turned his career around after struggling with the Pittsburgh Pirates in 2024. That makes it even more surprising that he wouldn’t want to try for a big deal. Especially with how valuable good relievers are.

But there are two potential reasons why he decided to accept the qualifying offer. One is that he wants to stay with the Yankees and accepted the qualifying offer in order to guarantee one more season. During the offseason, the two will work on an extension that will override the qualifying offer. There is also the fact that the $23.15 million salary makes him the highest-paid reliever in MLB history. Sure, he could get a long-term deal and get the security, but the dollar amount would be nowhere near that number.

Betr - Official Partner of Blitz Sports Media

The news that Jeffers was accepting the qualifying offer was even more surprising. For starters, he is a Scott Boors client, and Boors is notorious for getting his guys to the open market and getting them the most money. Jeffers is also coming off a pretty solid season. In 92 games, he slashed .256/.353/.461 with 14 home runs, 56 RBIs, and 127 OPS+. With several teams desperate for catchers, there would have been plenty of suitors for his services. He would have been one of the most sought-after free agents.

However, once you take a deeper dive into his numbers, it becomes clear why he accepted the qualifying offer. Back in May, he suffered a broken hamate bone that caused him to miss 46 games. After returning from injury, he wasn’t the same player. He slashed .231/.310/.417 with seven home runs and 30 RBIs after returning from injury. Sure, this is not bad production for a catcher, but it’s a drop in production from what it was before the injury. Accepting this offer gives him a season to prove that this was an outlier.

Although it was a bit of a surprise to see these two accept the qualifying offer, once you look at their season, it starts to make sense. They decided to take advantage of the high salary and bet on themself for this upcoming season. Then go into next offseason with fewer question marks and a better idea of what the financial situation in baseball will look like.

Screenshot 2026 08 10 120640 5

https://discord.gg/tKVupvzmpm

Share Via:
Brian Germinaro
Brian Germinaro