We got our first big trade of the MLB offseason as the Seattle Mariners are acquiring Maikel Garcia, along with James McArthur and a minor-league reliever, from the Kansas City Royals. In return, the Royals receive Bryce Miller, Jose Ferrer, and Logan Evans. In total, the deal involves five major-league players switching places. A trade like this is very rare in MLB. Normally, in big deals like this, one team acquires a big-name MLB player while the other gets a package of top prospects. But why did both sides agree to this deal?
Why the Mariners Made This Trade
Without question, the biggest name in this deal is Garcia. He has long been considered one of baseball’s best defensive third basemen. In 2026, he had an Outs Above Average of five, which ranked in the 89th percentile. While that is still good, it’s a bit of a step back from his 2025 numbers. That season, he posted a 17 Outs Above Average, which ranked in the 98th percentile. You should expect Garcia to fall somewhere in this range again next season. This will give them a huge advantage over the next four seasons.
While his defense has stayed consistent, his bat took a step back in 2026. In 82 games, he slashed .268/.344/.381 with three home runs, 38 RBIs, and a 102 OPS+. While you can live with those numbers, they’re nowhere near what he did in 2025. That year he posted a .286/.351/.449 slash line with 16 home runs, 74 RBIs, and a 121 OPS+. Sure, it was hard for him to repeat a career season, but no one saw a drop like this. Part of this drop-off could be due to him missing 80 games with injuries, and a healthy season could improve the numbers.
Along with Garcia, McArthur should be a solid addition to the Mariners bullpen. In his first full big-league season, he made 57 appearances last season; he posted a 4.92 ERA over 56 2/3 innings with 49 strikeouts to 14 walks, a 1.447 WHIP, and an 84 ERA+. He has a four-pitch mix that relies heavily on his sinker and curveball. Last season, he was great at limiting walks and producing ground balls. With T-Mobile Park being the most pitcher-friendly in baseball, we could see a big improvement from him this upcoming season.
Why the Royals Made This Trade
This trade was all about improving the Royals’ pitching staff. It was a gamble to trade someone like Garcia, who can make good contact and is defensively responsible. But if the players they acquired live up to expectations, it will be worth it. The headliner in this trade is Miller. He had a 4.17 ERA over 118 2/3 innings with 119 strikeouts to 38 walks, a 1.163 WHIP, and a 94 ERA+. But his underlying metrics suggest he should have better numbers. He ranks in the 91st percentile in Hard-Hit% and Chase%.
Miller relies heavily on his four-seamer, throwing it 39.8% of the time. He also has six other pitches in his arsenal that will keep hitters guessing. The big thing holding Miller back is injuries. Over his career, he has dealt with numerous finger and elbow injuries. Not exactly the track record you want when acquiring a pitcher. While he didn’t have an arm injury last year, he missed time with an oblique injury and pitched through a lat injury. The Royals will need to come up with some sort of strategy to keep him healthy.
Ferrer is a reliever with a ton of upside. Last season he had a 4.18 ERA over 64 2/3 innings with 54 strikeouts to 20 walks, a 1.469 WHIP, and a 94 ERA+. He relies mainly on his sinker, which averages out at 97.6 mph and ranks in the 92nd percentile. He also ranked in the 91st percentile in average exit velocity. He could be a solid middle reliever next season. Evans is still recovering from elbow surgery to place an internal brace on his UCL, which caused him to miss all of 2026. It’s unclear when he will be ready to return.



