Indianapolis and Houston meet for the second time this season, and the fantasy story in this one starts in Houston. C.J. Stroud has thrown eight touchdowns over his last two games, David Montgomery is expected back to lead the backfield with Woody Marks in the concussion protocol, and Tank Dell’s efficiency makes him one of the week’s most interesting flex plays. On the other side, Indianapolis’ passing game has been the least efficient in the league, which makes Daniel Jones and his receivers hard to trust and leaves Tyler Warren as the toughest call on the board. Houston is a 12.5-point favorite, so the Texans should control this game, and that shapes several of the decisions below.
Lineup Locks
Nico Collins, WR (HOU)
Jonathan Taylor, RB (IND)

Strong Starts
C.J. Stroud, QB (HOU)
C.J. Stroud’s touchdown production has surged. He’s thrown eight touchdowns over his last two games, including five against the Chargers in Week 9, and he’s the QB4 in fantasy points per game at 21.1. Among 36 qualifying quarterbacks, Stroud ranks sixth in adjusted net yards per attempt, fifth in passing touchdowns per game and third in end-zone attempts per game, so his scoring has been backed by real red-zone volume. He’s also been careful with the football, ranking seventh in turnover-worthy throw rate, and only 12.5% of his pressures have turned into sacks, the fourth-lowest rate in the league. His efficiency hasn’t been perfect, as he completed 20 of 38 passes for 211 yards and an interception against Cleveland despite his three touchdowns. He also scored just 11.7 fantasy points against Indianapolis in Week 3, his lowest total of the season.
The Colts’ defense looks different from the one Stroud saw in September. Indianapolis ranks 22nd in EPA allowed per dropback and has allowed the fifth-highest explosive play rate in the league. The Colts have also given up the eighth-most fantasy points per game to quarterbacks. Houston ranks sixth in pass rate over expectation, so Stroud should have plenty of chances to attack that secondary, and his end-zone volume gives him a strong path to multiple touchdowns. His Week 3 performance is the main reason for caution. I’m starting Stroud as a QB1 because his red-zone volume and a Colts defense that gives up big plays set him up for another strong game.
David Montgomery, RB (HOU)
David Montgomery is trending toward playing after missing Houston’s last four games with a groin injury. He practiced in full Tuesday, and DeMeco Ryans said he was trending in the right direction. Woody Marks remains in the concussion protocol and missed Tuesday’s practice, which leaves Montgomery as the likely lead back if he’s active. His efficiency before the injury was a real concern. Among 51 qualifying running backs, he ranked last in yards per carry (2.65) and EPA per attempt, and 57.7% of his carries were stuffed at or near the line. What kept him fantasy-relevant was his role near the goal line. He handled half of Houston’s carries inside the 5-yard line, and he opened the season with 20 carries for 60 yards and two touchdowns against Buffalo, adding three catches for 19 yards and a receiving touchdown for 28.9 PPR points.
The matchup and game script give Montgomery a strong path to volume. Indianapolis ranks 31st in EPA allowed per rush and has given up the sixth-most fantasy points per game to running backs this season. Houston was a 12.5-point favorite as of Wednesday, which sets up a second half where the Texans should lean on the run. Montgomery managed just 33 yards on 11 carries against the Colts in Week 3, and his efficiency numbers make it hard to expect a big yardage day. He could also share some work with Emari Demercado in his first game back. If he’s active and Marks is out, I’m starting Montgomery as an RB2 because his workload and touchdown opportunities outweigh his poor efficiency in this matchup.
Tank Dell, WR (HOU)
Tank Dell has been one of the most efficient receivers in football when he’s on the field. He’s averaging 3.52 yards per route run and 0.29 targets per route run, both near the top of the league, and he ranks in the 99th percentile in win rate and the 97th percentile in separation. He’s also averaging 9.9 yards after the catch per reception, and half of his receptions have been explosive plays. The problem is his playing time. Dell ran a route on 55% of Houston’s dropbacks in each of the last two games, including against Cleveland with Marvin Harrison Jr. already sidelined. That’s why his production has swung, from 20.5 PPR points against the Chargers in Week 9 to 5.1 against the Browns.
Harrison is unlikely to play again Thursday, but his absence last week didn’t move Dell’s route share, so I’m not counting on a jump in playing time. The more promising sign is that Dell has been lining up in the slot more often, which gives him a possible path to more routes if Houston keeps moving him inside. The Colts have allowed the fifth-highest explosive play rate in the league, which fits a receiver who turns targets into big gains as often as Dell does. Still, a 55% route share leaves him with a low floor. I’m starting Dell as a high-risk flex, because his efficiency and big-play ability give him upside, but his limited role means a quiet game is just as possible.

On the Fence
Tyler Warren, TE (IND)
Tyler Warren’s usage is among the best at the position. Among 48 qualifying tight ends, he ranks fifth in routes per game and fourth in targets per game, and he’s commanded 21.4% of Indianapolis’ targets with a 20.4% first-read share. He’s on the field for 87.1% of the Colts’ snaps and ranks sixth in targets per route run. That’s the profile of a TE1, and he’s the TE7 in fantasy points per game at 10.8. The volume has been there, but he hasn’t turned it into enough yardage, ranking 36th in yards per route run, 34th in win rate and 37th in yards after the catch per reception. He’s scored fewer than 9 PPR points in three straight games, bottoming out at 2.4 against Miami.
The quarterback play is the biggest obstacle. Indianapolis ranks last in the league in EPA per dropback, and Daniel Jones threw for just 108 yards against Miami. Houston has also been tough on tight ends, allowing the seventh-fewest PPR points per game to the position. The best argument for Warren is what he did against the Texans in Week 3, catching nine of 10 targets for 55 yards and adding two rushing yards for 14.7 PPR points. With Josh Downs and Keenan Allen traded and Alec Pierce on injured reserve, there’s almost no one else for Jones to throw to, and the Colts should be passing plenty as heavy underdogs. I’d start Warren if you don’t have another reliable tight end, because his target volume gives him a path to a useful game. If you have a solid alternative, I’d lean that way until the Colts’ passing game shows it can produce.
Sit ’Em
Daniel Jones, QB (IND)
Daniel Jones has been one of the least efficient quarterbacks in football. Among 36 qualifying passers, he ranks 34th in EPA per dropback, 35th in completion percentage over expectation and 35th in adjusted net yards per attempt, and he has the second-highest turnover-worthy throw rate in the league at 6.5%. That’s shown up in the box score, as he completed 11 of 22 passes for 108 yards, a touchdown and two interceptions against Miami while adding nine rushing yards, finishing with 5.2 fantasy points. He’s the QB33 in fantasy points per game at 10.2, and he’s thrown eight interceptions over his last five games. He’s also fallen 32.4 points short of his expected fantasy production this season, which shows how often the Colts’ passing game has failed to finish drives.
Houston has allowed the 11th-most fantasy points per game to quarterbacks, which isn’t a matchup that should scare fantasy managers away on its own. The Colts could also be throwing a lot if they fall behind early. But Jones hasn’t shown he can take advantage of passing volume, and his turnover problems make every extra attempt a risk. Even with plenty of attempts, his lack of downfield production makes it difficult to project a useful fantasy performance. I’m sitting Jones because Indianapolis’ passing offense has been the worst in the league, and he doesn’t have the weapons to turn that around this week.
Seth McGowan, RB (IND)
Seth McGowan has scored touchdowns in back-to-back games, including 12 carries for 77 yards and a score against Miami. He handled 35% of the Colts’ carries in that game, his highest share of the season. However, Jonathan Taylor remains the lead back, and McGowan’s snap share actually dropped from 31% to 29% last week. He also hasn’t contributed as a receiver, with five catches for nine yards all season, so his production depends entirely on carries and touchdowns.
That leaves him exposed in this matchup. Houston is a heavy favorite, and if Indianapolis falls behind, McGowan has little receiving work to fall back on. The Texans have also been close to league average against running backs, allowing the 14th-most PPR points per game to the position. McGowan’s touchdown streak makes him tempting, but a backup with no receiving role is hard to trust in a game his team could trail. I’m sitting McGowan because his production depends on carries and touchdowns, and this game could limit both.
Laquon Treadwell, WR (IND)
Laquon Treadwell caught three of three targets for 24 yards and a touchdown against Miami, finishing with 11.4 PPR points. That was his best game in more than a month, and the touchdown carried it. Treadwell has been on the field plenty, running a route on 70.1% of the Colts’ dropbacks, but he hasn’t earned targets when he’s out there. Among 117 qualifying receivers, he ranks 104th in targets per route run and 100th in yards per route run, and he’s commanded just 9.5% of Indianapolis’ targets. Before last week, he scored 4.1, 3.9, 2.8 and zero PPR points in four straight games.
Houston has allowed the third-most PPR points per game to wide receivers, which is the best argument for considering Treadwell. But he’s attached to the least efficient passing offense in football, and his target share hasn’t grown even with the Colts’ receiver room thinning out. He’s unlikely to see enough volume to deliver a reliable game. I’m sitting Treadwell because his target share is too low to trust, even in a favorable matchup.
Xavier Hutchinson, WR (HOU)
Xavier Hutchinson has scored a touchdown in three straight games, and he earned a real workload against Cleveland, catching four of nine targets for 58 yards and a score. He was still Houston’s primary slot receiver in that game, and his route-running has been encouraging, ranking eighth among 117 qualifying receivers in win rate. However, he’s caught just 54.9% of his targets, which ranks 90th among qualifiers, and he’s running a route on just 59.9% of Houston’s dropbacks. He’s also fallen 6.2 points short of his expected fantasy production this season, which suggests there could be more production available if his catch rate improves. The question is whether his role holds.
Tank Dell has been lining up in the slot more often, and if that continues, it could cut into Hutchinson’s routes. Indianapolis also hasn’t been an easy matchup for slot receivers recently, allowing the 11th-fewest PPR points per game to the position over its last five games. With Collins as the clear top target and Houston likely leaning on its running game with a big lead, Hutchinson’s target total is hard to predict from week to week. He’s a touchdown-dependent flex in deeper leagues. I’m sitting Hutchinson in shallower leagues because Houston’s receiver rotation makes his target share too uncertain to trust.
Dalton Schultz, TE (HOU)
Dalton Schultz has been efficient this season, but his role in Houston’s passing game has shrunk over the last month. Among 48 qualifying tight ends, he ranks ninth in targets per route run and 13th in yards per route run, and he’s the TE19 in fantasy points per game at 8.8. He’s scored just 0.11 touchdowns per game, 32nd among qualifiers, and he’s dropped 8.2% of his targets, one of the highest rates at the position. The biggest concern is his recent volume. After drawing 19% and 21% of the Texans’ targets in Weeks 6 and 7, he’s seen just 9% and 6% over his last two games. He caught one pass for 11 yards and a touchdown against Cleveland for 8.1 PPR points.
Indianapolis has been an average matchup for tight ends, allowing the 15th-most PPR points per game to the position. That isn’t enough to overcome Schultz’s shrinking target share, especially with Collins, Dell and Hutchinson all ahead of him in Houston’s passing game. If the Texans build a big lead and lean on the run, Schultz’s target total could drop even further. I’m sitting Schultz because his recent target share is too low to trust, and he’s unlikely to see enough volume to deliver a useful fantasy performance.



