Week 2 is where the panic meter starts heating up.
One bad game? Usually nothing to worry about. But when poor efficiency, questionable usage, injuries, or a troubling role start stacking up, it’s time to take a closer look.
Here are five players whose fantasy managers should have very different levels of concern heading into Week 3.
Saquon Barkley – Panic Meter 7/10
The injury is the biggest concern, but the efficiency was ugly even before that.
Saquon Barkley was already having a rough afternoon before a stinger forced him out of the game. He briefly left in the first quarter, returned after halftime wearing a neck roll, and ultimately finished with just 4 carries for 9 yards (2.2 YPC) and one catch for 11 yards. He is scheduled to undergo an MRI on the stinger.
And this wasn’t exactly a matchup where we expected him to get completely shut down. After rushing for 83 yards on 15 carries in Week 1, Barkley has now averaged just 4.8 yards per carry across two games, with only 19 total carries, 92 rushing yards, and zero touchdowns. He is averaging just 6.0 PPR points per game through two weeks.
The bigger issue is that Philadelphia’s rushing attack hasn’t generated much efficiency either. The Eagles managed only 89 rushing yards as a team against Tennessee, averaging 2.8 YPC. In the first two games, they’ve had a 32% success rate in early down runs, which is the worst in the NFL.
Obviously, the stinger has to be monitored before making any long-term conclusions. But when you’re talking about a first-round fantasy pick, the combination of poor efficiency, limited scoring production, and now more injury concerns, this is enough to move an almost 30-year-old back all the way up to a 7/10.
The good news: it’s only Week 2, and his talent and offensive environment haven’t disappeared.
The bad news: you didn’t draft Barkley at the Round1-2 turn to get six fantasy points per game.
Jameson Williams- Panic Meter 9/10
This is exactly why Jameson Williams was one of the riskiest players in fantasy football entering the season.
Williams finished Week 2 with just 2 catches for 33 yards on 4 targets, giving him only 13 fantasy points combined through two games. And the Thursday night game ended 41-31, so there was plenty of scoring opportunity. But here’s the important part: the problem isn’t simply that he’s playing badly. It’s that we have no idea when the good games are coming.
Williams entered the season as the definition of a boom-or-bust fantasy player. He can win you a week with two explosive plays, but he can also disappear completely, even when the matchup looks good.
And that’s exactly what happened last Thursday.
The scary part is that the Lions offense is loaded with other mouths to feed. Amon-Ra St. Brown is the clear No. 1 target, Sam LaPorta is back healthy, and Jahmyr Gibbs remains heavily involved in the passing game. Last season, Willaim averaged 10.94 PPR points per game with LaPorta active, compared with 15.08 without him.
That split is extremely important for 2026 so far.
Williams Week 1 usage initially gave fantasy managers reason for optimism- he had 23.1% target share, 36% first-read share, and 61% air yard share- but he still produced only 45 yards and dropped two passes.
Then Week 2 came, and the value disappeared. That’s the nightmare scenario: you can’t confidently start him until there is a major injury to the other 3 stars. This is not necessarily a talent problem. It’s a weekly predictability problem, and that’s enough to keep him on my bench and a panic meter of 9/10.
Jayden Daniels – Panic Meter 8/10
This one is about the injury more than the fantasy performance.
Daniels was actually putting together a solid start to his fantasy year before disaster struck. He finished the first half against Dallas with 69 rushing yards and a touchdown pass, completing 11-of-17 passes for 96 yards. Then, on the final play of the half, he dislocated his left-elbow- the same elbow he previously injured. Initial testing showed no fracture, but further evaluation is needed to determine ligament damage and whether surgery is necessary.
That’s obviously a massive concern for fantasy managers. Daniel’s rushing ability is such a huge part of his fantasy ceiling, but that same rushing style exposes him to more hits than a traditional pocket passer. Now he’s dealing with another elbow injury to the same arm.
The other concern to begin with was Washington’s offensive line.
The Commanders entered the season with questions up front, and their Week 2 depth chart features Brandon Coleman, Chris Paul, Nick Allegretti, Sam Cosmi, and Josh Conerly Jr. across the line. Washington also dealt with additional offensive-line injuries during Sunday’s game.
So even if Daniels returns relatively quickly, fantasy managers have to consider the possibility that the injury could affect how aggressively he runs- or that he could be exposed to additional hits behind a shaky offensive line.
There’s no reason to panic about his talent. The panic is entirely about availability and the possibility that the injury changes his rushing-based fantasy profile.
David Montgomery – Panic Meter 6/10
The touchdown regression was coming- and Houston’s offense isn’t exactly giving him a ton of opportunities to score either.
Montgomery was one of my favorite sell-high candidates after Week 1, and Week 2 only reinforced why.
After scoring three touchdowns in the first game, Montgomery is already becoming increasingly dependent on touchdowns and positive game script to provide a big fantasy day. And the Bills and Bengals are both known for not being the best at stopping the run.
The Week 2 numbers were ugly: 6 carries for 10 yards (1.7 YPC), and 2 catches for 114 yards. Meanwhile, the entire Texans rushing attack produced only 18 yards on 14 carries… that’s really poor.
And that’s the bigger issue.
Houston’s offense has now failed to score a touchdown on 16 consecutive possessions, is 0-2, and just got completely shut down on the ground by Cincinnati. The Texans also allowed four sacks in the game. Montgomery isn’t getting the kind of workload that allows him to overcome poor efficiency without touchdowns.
And then there’s the other elephant in the room: Woody Marks.
Through the first two gams, the Texans have essentially treated this as a split backfield. Montgomery 49% and 51% snaps, Marks 51% and 48% snap share. That’s not what you want to see from a player you hoped would provide RB2 production entering a change of scenery.
Monty is also entering his age-29 season, so expecting his best efficiency to continue indefinitely isn’t exactly a safe bet. He’s still useful, particularly around the goal line, but how many times is Houston going to be in the red zone? His fantasy value is becoming heavily dependent on touchdowns + game script + limited completion.
That’s a dangerous combination.
Jeremiyah Love – Panic Meter 2/10
Do NOT panic. This is the guy I’m trying to buy low on.
If you drafted Jeremiyah Love expecting him to immediately dominate the Cardinals backfield, Week 2 probably wasn’t what you wanted. But this is exactly the type of situation where fantasy managers can overreact.
Love entered the season as a rookie with plenty of talent, and his limited workload was expected. In Week 1, he played only 44.4% of snaps, with 32.4% designed carry share, 38.5% route share, and 8.1% target share. He still managed 13 touches for 50 total yards and a touchdown.
Then in Week 2, Love actually led Arizona’s back in carries, getting 9 carries compared with 5 for Tyler Allegeir, while adding three catches for 16 yards.
That’s important.
The role isn’t fully there yet, but the opportunity is trending in the right direction. Love also showed excellent efficiency in his limited Week 1 workload, averaging 4.0 yards after contact per attempt and forcing a missed tackle on 27% of his attempts. Also, have to remember he was coming back from a high-ankle injury that left him sidelined for about a month prior to the season.
This is where patience matters.
Rookie running backs often see their roles expand as the season progresses, and Love has the talent profile to make a significant jump once Arizona gives him more work. I’m not selling because of two mediocre weeks. I’m buying.
If another manager is frustrated with a slow start, this is exactly the type of player I’d be trying to acquire before the workload catches up with the talent.
Final Panic Meter
Saquon Barkley- 7/10
Jameson Williams – 9/10
Jayden Daniels – 8/10
David Montgomery- 6/10
Jeremiyah Love- 2/10
– Follow me on X @ChrisDegz and don’t forget to check our main page for coverage of college football, NFL, fantasy football, and a few best bets added.
