Fantasy football managers know that every lineup decision can make or break a week, and choosing the right players to start or sit is where championships are won. With the 2026 NFL season underway, matchups, stats, and trends are more important than ever. From favorable matchups and scoring trends to players you should avoid in tough spots, my weekly positional start and sit guide is built to give you an edge.
Want your start/sit questions answered within minutes? Join the Blitz Community for free fantasy football advice all season long.
DEF to Start
New Orleans Saints
New Orleans hasn’t been the type of defense I’m looking to blindly start every week, but this is much more about the matchup than pretending the Saints have suddenly become an elite fantasy unit. The encouraging part is that New Orleans has been able to generate pressure, recording eight sacks through three games. That gives this defense a path toward fantasy production even if it doesn’t completely shut down the opposing offense. Atlanta finally broke through offensively last week, scoring 35 points against Green Bay after producing only 16 total points across its first two games. Michael Penix Jr. looked considerably better in his return, while Bijan Robinson and Drake London gave the Falcons the explosive production that had been missing. That performance deserves respect, but I’m also not ready to let one game completely erase what we saw from this offense over the first two weeks.
That’s why I’m comfortable taking a chance on New Orleans at home. Atlanta’s Week 3 explosion was its first consistently productive offensive performance of the season, and now Penix gets a Saints defense that has shown it can create pressure through three games. That’s important because I don’t need New Orleans to completely shut down Robinson or London for this start to work. A few sacks combined with one or two turnover opportunities would be enough to give the Saints a useful fantasy floor, especially if the offense can keep the game competitive and prevent Atlanta from leaning entirely on the run. This isn’t the safest defensive start of the week, but if I’m streaming the position, New Orleans has enough sack upside in this matchup to make them one of my preferred options.
Green Bay Packers
Green Bay is coming off its worst defensive performance of the season, allowing Atlanta to score 35 points while Bijan Robinson and Drake London repeatedly created explosive plays. I’m not going to pretend that performance wasn’t concerning, but I’m also not throwing out what this defense showed over the first two weeks because of one bad Thursday night. The Packers have seven sacks and two interceptions through three games, so there has still been enough pressure and turnover production to give us fantasy upside. More importantly, the situation they’re walking into this week is dramatically different from the one they just faced against Atlanta.
Baker Mayfield is out with a dislocated thumb, leaving rookie Jalon Daniels to make his first NFL start for Tampa Bay. Daniels attempted only three passes after replacing Mayfield last week, completing none of them and throwing an interception on a Hail Mary. Now his first start comes against a Green Bay defense that already has seven sacks through three games. Tampa Bay can try to protect Daniels with the running game and shorter throws, but if Green Bay can establish a lead and force the rookie into obvious passing situations, the opportunities for sacks and turnovers should increase considerably. That’s enough for me to go right back to the Packers after last week’s disappointment.
Buffalo Bills
Buffalo is one of my favorite defensive starts this week because New England continues giving opposing defenses exactly the type of opportunities we’re looking for. The Bills have nine sacks through three games, and the pass rush should have another chance to create problems against an offense that has already allowed nine sacks. Buffalo hasn’t been dominant in every defensive category, but that’s less important to me when we’re talking about fantasy D/ST. Sacks and turnovers are what can separate a useful fantasy performance from a defense that simply limits yardage, and Buffalo has a path toward both in this matchup.
Drake Maye is the biggest reason I’m willing to trust them. Maye turned the ball over three more times against Jacksonville last week, throwing two interceptions and losing a fumble in New England’s 35-6 loss. He’s now responsible for seven turnovers through three games, while the Patriots are averaging only 12 points per game. That’s a combination I want to attack. Buffalo’s offense can also contribute to the game script if Josh Allen and company establish an early lead and force New England to throw more aggressively. Maye still has enough talent and rushing ability to make plays, but until the turnovers slow down, I’m comfortable continuing to start fantasy defenses against this Patriots offense.
DEF to Sit
Philadelphia Eagles
Philadelphia is a defense I’m much more comfortable holding than starting this week. The Eagles have plenty of defensive talent, but the fantasy production hasn’t followed through three games. They’ve recorded only three sacks and have yet to intercept a pass, leaving them without two of the easiest paths toward a ceiling performance at D/ST. That doesn’t mean Philadelphia is suddenly a bad real-life defense. It means we’re being asked to start a unit that hasn’t created many splash plays in a week where the opponent makes finding those plays considerably more difficult.
The Rams are the problem. Matthew Stafford has thrown for 872 yards and six touchdowns through three games, and Los Angeles has already produced multiple 500-yard offensive performances. Stafford has thrown four interceptions, so there is some turnover upside here, but Sean McVay’s offense can create problems without giving Philadelphia many clean pass-rush opportunities. This is one of those situations where the Eagles could play perfectly respectable defense and still give us a mediocre fantasy score. With only three sacks and no interceptions through three games, I’m not forcing them into my lineup against one of the league’s more dangerous passing attacks.
Denver Broncos
Sitting Denver is uncomfortable because the defense itself has been producing exactly the type of plays we want for fantasy. The Broncos have eight sacks through three games, tied near the top of the league, and their four interceptions are among the NFL’s best totals. That’s a strong profile, and this isn’t a case where I’m suddenly questioning the quality of Denver’s defense. If anything, the first three weeks have reinforced why this is a unit I’m comfortable holding through difficult matchups rather than dropping whenever the schedule gets tougher.
I just don’t like the matchup with San Francisco enough to chase the season-long production. Brock Purdy has thrown nine touchdowns against only one interception while completing more than 72% of his passes through three games, and the 49ers have enough weapons to make life difficult even for an excellent defense. Christian McCaffrey, George Kittle, and the rest of this offense can also punish aggressive defenses without requiring Purdy to repeatedly hold the football and expose himself to pressure. Denver’s pass rush and secondary always give it a chance to create a big play, so I’m certainly not dropping this defense. But against a quarterback with a 9:1 touchdown-to-interception ratio, I’d rather stream a unit facing an offense giving us a clearer path toward sacks and turnovers.
New England Patriots
New England’s actual defensive performance has been considerably better than its 1-2 record suggests. The Patriots are allowing only 278.3 yards and 17 points per game through three weeks, while their seven sacks show they can still generate pressure. That’s why this isn’t me calling New England a bad defense. The bigger issue with fantasy D/ST is that matchup can matter just as much as overall defensive quality, and this is about as difficult of a spot as we can give them.
Buffalo enters Week 4 averaging 33.7 points and more than 400 yards of offense per game. Josh Allen has already thrown for 786 yards and five touchdowns while adding six rushing scores, and James Cook has 346 rushing yards at 6.0 yards per carry. That gives New England very few obvious weaknesses to attack. The Patriots could play solid defense for stretches and still give up enough points and yardage to limit their fantasy ceiling, especially if Buffalo protects the football. New England will have much better spots later in the season. On the road against one of the NFL’s highest-scoring offenses, I’m keeping the Patriots on the bench.
Kickers to Start
Will Reichard MIN
Will Reichard has become one of the easiest kickers to trust through three weeks because Minnesota continues giving him opportunities and he hasn’t wasted them. Reichard is a perfect 7-for-7 on field goals this season, including three makes in each of the past two games. He also showed off the range again last week, connecting from 56 yards against Tampa Bay after making from 49 the week before. That’s what I want from a fantasy kicker: an offense capable of consistently crossing midfield combined with a kicker who can turn stalled drives into points from well beyond 50 yards.
Miami gives me no reason to move away from him. Reichard has attempted seven field goals through three games, and his range means the Vikings don’t necessarily need to reach the red zone before he’s in scoring position. He’s already produced multiple field goals in consecutive weeks, and now he gets another home matchup where Minnesota should have opportunities to put points on the board. Kicker can be extremely volatile week to week, but Reichard’s combination of accuracy, range, and opportunity makes him one of my preferred Week 4 starts.
Trey Smack GB
Trey Smack’s Week 3 fantasy line was disappointing, but I’m much more interested in what he showed during the first two games. Smack made all five of his field-goal attempts over that stretch, including a 59-yarder in Week 1, before having his only attempt blocked against Atlanta last week. The range is clearly there, and Green Bay has already trusted him with multiple attempts in two of its first three games. I’m not moving away from that profile because one kick was blocked in a game where the entire Packers offense struggled.
Tampa Bay is a good spot for Green Bay’s offense to rebound, especially with Baker Mayfield unavailable on the other side. If the Packers can control more of the game with rookie Jalon Daniels starting for Tampa Bay, Smack should have a better chance to benefit from sustained drives and favorable field position. Jordan Love and the Packers don’t need to score touchdowns every time they cross midfield for this start to work. Smack has already shown that Green Bay is comfortable letting him attempt long field goals, and that range gives him legitimate upside whenever drives stall outside the red zone.
Spencer Shrader IND
Spencer Shrader has quietly been one of the best fantasy kickers through three weeks. He’s a perfect 8-for-8 on field goals, and last week was his biggest performance yet, making all four attempts against Houston with two coming from beyond 50 yards. He also hit three field goals against Kansas City the week before, meaning Indianapolis has now given him seven attempts over its past two games. That’s the type of volume I’m looking to chase at kicker, especially when the player has already shown he can convert from long range.
Washington gives Shrader another opportunity to keep that going. Indianapolis has given him seven field-goal attempts over the past two games, which is exactly the type of opportunity I’m looking for at kicker. He’s already 8-for-8 through three games and has made four field goals from 40-plus yards over the past two weeks, including two from beyond 50 yards against Houston. There is one serious situation to monitor before locking him into lineups: Shrader aggravated a groin injury during pregame warmups last week. Indianapolis remains encouraged about his Week 4 availability, but I want confirmation that he’s active before starting him. Assuming he’s cleared to kick, the recent combination of volume and range keeps him firmly in my Week 4 lineup.
Kickers to Sit
Chase McLaughlin TB
Chase McLaughlin has actually been excellent through three weeks, which makes this a situation where I’m fading the offensive environment rather than the kicker. He’s made all nine of his field-goal attempts this season, including kicks from 51, 59, and 54 yards. Tampa Bay has repeatedly given him opportunities, and McLaughlin has taken advantage of them. If Baker Mayfield were healthy, there would be very little reason for me to move away from a kicker producing at that level.
Mayfield’s thumb injury changes the equation considerably. Rookie Jalon Daniels is making his first NFL start against Green Bay after going 0-for-3 in relief last week, and now we’re asking Tampa Bay to consistently move the football far enough for McLaughlin to remain involved. McLaughlin’s range gives him some protection because the Buccaneers don’t need to reach the red zone for him to score, but even a great kicker needs his offense to cross midfield. With a rookie quarterback making his first start against a Packers defense that already has seven sacks, I’m lowering expectations and would rather chase a kicker attached to a more stable offense.
Cameron Dicker LAC
Cameron Dicker finally gave fantasy managers some production last week, making three of four field-goal attempts against Buffalo after an almost nonexistent role over the first two games. The problem is that one productive week doesn’t completely erase what we saw before it. Dicker didn’t attempt a field goal in Week 1 and missed his only attempt in Week 2, meaning last week’s four opportunities account for 80% of his field-goal attempts this season. He’s now 3-for-5 overall, and the Chargers simply haven’t given us a consistent enough kicking environment to make him someone I want to automatically start.
Seattle doesn’t make me more interested in chasing last week’s performance. This is a difficult road matchup, and there’s a real possibility Los Angeles again struggles to consistently move into scoring range. Dicker is a talented kicker, so this isn’t about doubting his ability. It’s about opportunity. One game with four attempts doesn’t outweigh two weeks where he received only one combined field-goal opportunity. Until the Chargers show they can consistently put Dicker in position for multiple attempts, I’d rather use a kicker attached to a more reliable scoring environment.
Tyler Bass BUF
Tyler Bass is attached to one of the highest-scoring offenses in football, but that hasn’t translated into consistent field-goal volume. Buffalo is averaging 33.7 points per game, yet Bass has attempted only four field goals through three weeks. He didn’t attempt one at all against Detroit in Week 2 and received only one attempt against the Chargers last week. The Bills are scoring plenty of points; they’re just finishing too many of those drives with touchdowns for Bass to consistently benefit.
New England is another matchup where that could become a problem. Buffalo enters as one of the league’s most productive offenses, while the Patriots have allowed only 17 points per game through three weeks. That creates two potential outcomes I don’t particularly love for Bass: either Buffalo continues finishing drives with touchdowns, or New England’s defense succeeds in limiting the number of scoring possessions altogether. Bass obviously has upside whenever Josh Allen is moving the offense this efficiently, but kicker production depends on drives ending in a very specific area of the field. With only four field-goal attempts through three games, I’d rather chase a kicker receiving more consistent opportunities.
